View the episode, The Simpsons - Season 27 - Episode 1 - "Every Man's Dream," here
The curator of SleepyheadCENTRAL has a few thoughts about bringing this groundbreaking subject to popular culture:
1. Any time you can bring awareness of health issues before large, varied populations, you are opening up space for a dialog and better understanding of the disease being highlighted; even if/when the portrayal of the disease is not completely inaccurate or there are other flaws in the narrative, it's still a jumping off point and that's pretty important.
2. The Simpsons is poised to not only bring critical attention to the very real sleep disorder that is narcolepsy, but in broader fashion, to show insight into what it is like to live with invisible illness.
4. Television and film often get some of the details wrong when it comes to subjects from the realm of science. But we have to remember that these are fictionalized visual narratives with specific goals to meet within a metered course of time and often the choices writer and directors make in teleplays and screenplays are compromises between accuracy and information relay as a form of transition. We cannot expect The Simpsons to be the best way to learn about narcolepsy but it might be the most widely distributed way to get the conversation started and maybe this is what matters most. You have to start somewhere... it may as well be before a bunch of avid viewers.
5. That Homer would be portrayed as using his diagnosis as a crutch to withdraw from his daily duties is a little troubling, nonetheless. People with sleep disorders and fatigue issues often have lives with full agendas--people to care for, jobs to go to, households to maintain, social lives to engage. Their conditions often mean they have to bow out of activities or sleep when they should be doing things, and their friends and family may often interpret this behavior as laziness or an excuse to shirk responsibility. However, narcolepsy is not the kind of illness you just power through. You can't. The brain will shut down biochemically when triggered and you are left to recharge it, and these moments of activity and recharge are random or, at the very least, incompatible with the schedules and time frames of people living normal lives. Listen, we all know Homer has many flaws, one of which is his general laziness, which has nothing to do with narcolepsy. But to put the two together to show cause and effect is a real disservice to many people who struggle to keep up with normal life because of their conditions and who are routinely judged by their loved ones, coworkers and perfect strangers as being lazy when in fact they are ill and cannot help themselves.
6. I do wonder about a rise in narcolepsy "self diagnosis" as a result of this new subject matter. People may go to see "Dr. Google," look up narcolepsy, consider the symptoms, and decide for themselves that they have narcolepsy. Here's the deal, though: you cannot treat narcolepsy without a doctor's examination, which will include an overnight sleep study and a series of daytime nap tests the following day (at the very least). Despite what they show in the episode of The Simpsons, you are not likely to receive a spinal tap checking your hypocretin levels as this test is expensive and has risk factors. The sleep lab diagnostics are just as accurate and a lot less expensive, plus they will identify any hidden sleep problems you might be experiencing without your knowledge. Which would be a good thing, too. But don't think that you will be able to ask for any of the medications they use to treat narcolepsy without getting an accurate diagnosis first: these are dispensed under tight surveillance via specialty pharmacies or otherwise extraordinary protocols.
7. For the record, narcolepsy is usually identified earlier in one's life (late teens to mid-twenties). Still, Homer's late discovery of his condition isn't unrealistic: some people go for years before properly identifying their narcolepsy, as much about it has been poorly understood until only recently.
8. What is also pretty accurate is the strain that having narcolepsy can place on a relationship, especially if the person suffering has to stop working or contributing to the household because of it. No wonder Marge and Homer considered separating; it happens to many couples when one of the two is suffering a chronic illness that threatens economic well being or a sense of unity at home.
Read more about what others think about Homer's new diagnosis here and what it might mean for public awareness of narcolepsy:
- CNN || It's not just the Duff making Homer Simpson sleepy -- he has narcolepsy
- JULIE FLYGARE || The Simpsons Modifies Homer Narcolepsy Episode “Somewhat” After Reading Narcolepsy Article
- THE WEEK || The Simpsons shows why narcolepsy is no laughing matter
- YOUTH HEALTH || Homer Simpson diagnosed with narcolepsy; what is it?